Automation is outpacing the people who maintain it
UK manufacturers are adding robots and connected machinery faster than they can train the engineers to keep them running. Berend Booms, Head of Enterprise Asset Management Insights at Ultimo argues that the answer lies in how maintenance knowledge is captured and shared, not just in recruitment.
Walk around most UK factories today and you’ll see two generations of equipment working side by side. A robot cell installed last year feeds a packaging line that has been running since the 1990s. A new vision system checks parts coming off a press that’s older than some of the people operating it. Each upgrade makes the line faster and more capable. Each one also adds a layer of complexity that somebody needs to navigate at two in the morning when it stops.
That part rarely makes it into the business case. Automation projects are planned around throughput, labour savings and payback. Far fewer are planned around who will be left to maintain the equipment in five years’ time, and what they’ll need to know.
The people problem
The numbers are hard to ignore. Make UK reports that nearly three-quarters of manufacturers see a shortage of technical skills as the biggest barrier to recruitment, and the IET has found that 76 percent of engineering and technology employers struggle to fill key roles. Apprenticeship starts in manufacturing and engineering have fallen by around 40 percent since the Apprenticeship Levy was introduced. Meanwhile, the existing workforce is getting older. In Ultimo’s Maintenance Trend Report, 63 percent of maintenance professionals named the ageing workforce as the most pressing trend affecting their maintenance strategy.
You can see the effect in repair times. Siemens research found that average repair times at the world’s largest companies rose from 49 to 81 minutes in five years. Machines haven’t become dramatically harder to fix in that time. What has changed is who’s fixing them, and what help they have when they do.
Why recruitment alone won’t fix it
The instinct is to treat this as an HR problem – hire more engineers, train more apprentices. Both matter, but neither closes the gap quickly enough, because the shortage isn’t only of people. It’s of knowledge.
Every site has a handful of engineers who know its equipment inside out. They know which conveyor trips when the hall gets humid, which controller needs a particular reset sequence and which bearing always goes first. Very little of that is written down, and for older or mixed generation kit it often isn’t in any manual either. When those people retire or move on, the knowledge leaves with them, and no job advert brings it back.
New automation makes this harder. Every additional system adds to what a technician might need to know, and the newest kit is often the least familiar.
What works
The manufacturers handling this well tend to do three things.
First, they plan maintenance as part of the automation project, not after it. Before new equipment goes in, they agree who will look after it, which spares need to be on the shelf, what training is needed and how faults and fixes will be recorded. That’s far easier to set up at installation than once the warranty has run out.
Second, they capture knowledge at the point of work. Rather than asking busy engineers to write up procedures at the end of a shift, they use a mobile device to quickly record a voice note or photo attached to the job and linked to the specific machine. Over time, that builds a history of what went wrong and what fixed it, available to whoever works on that asset next.
Third, they focus support on the least experienced shift, not the strongest. Your best engineers will cope with most problems. The real risk sits with the newer technician on nights, facing an unfamiliar fault alone. AI-assisted troubleshooting can help here by pulling up similar past faults, the fixes that worked and the relevant manual pages in seconds. It can’t replace experience, and it shouldn’t make safety decisions on its own, but it does mean a newer engineer isn’t starting from scratch.
A checklist for engineering managers
- Before signing off any automation project, name who will maintain it and how
- List the machines on site that only one person knows how to fix and start there.
- Make recording a fault and its fix take less than a minute using mobile technology
- Pair experienced engineers with newer staff on complex jobs, and capture what gets shared
- Track mean time to repair by shift as well as by site. The gaps will show you where support is needed.
Automation will keep advancing, and it should. But manuals only capture procedure: steps, settings, part numbers. What keeps a line running is tribal knowledge, such as the sound of a failing bearing or the smell of a motor running hot. Record those observations against the machine, and the newest technician on nights can draw on decades of experience.















